Food or Cars?Just reading an article about the US government's plans to develop a parallel mechanism to the Kyoto Protocol to deal with global warming. I firmly hope it goes nowhere because as bad as Kyoto is (did you know that aviation is excluded from Kyoto?) any plan developed by the Bush Administration would be a nightmare. Anyway this article mentioned how exited the US, Brazil and other countries are in developing biofuels or biodiesel as an alternative to imported oil. Despite their glad-handing and jubilation, biodiesel is a nightmare waiting to happen. For one it's going to make the price of food soar. This will destroy the livelihoods of poor people in Canada and beyond. Mexico is already seeing the price of their staple, corn rise in response to rich North Americans' desire to drive "sustainably". I also found an article linking a rise in beer prices in Germany to biodiesel. This is only the beginning. Most industrial food production already relies on huge energy inputs. Currently we are essentially eating oil and taking more from the earth than we put in. To produce say 100 food calories you have to input say 1000 oil calories. This is the definition of unsustainable. So if we're going to move to biodiesel we'll need to spend most of the harvest fueling up our giant agricultural machinery. And what will be the result. Some will drive and continue to live high on the hog while others will starve. Sounds just to me! At the same time, I recognize that the human population on earth is highly dangerous and is endangering the survival of this most perfect world. We could do with a decrease in membership. So I find this to be a sticky situation in terms of my moral approach to this violent gamble on biodiesel. If only we could step back and choose to decrease our population in a responsible and thoughtful way instead of creating new structures that will cause intense hardship and suffering. But that would be giving our species too much credit. And is capitalist democracy even able to make these vital choices? Does the failure of Kyoto and the primacy of the "economy" demonstrate that this is the case?Labels: Business, Civilization, Climate Change, Future, Peak Oil